Why conscious AI could upend the corporate business model
People still debate whether AI is truly intelligent, though its capabilities make that dismissal increasingly difficult. More often now, the question is whether AI can ever be conscious. Philosophers, cognitive psychologists and computer scientists debate the theories and evidence.
Let’s assume that machines will one day become convincingly conscious: beings with experiences, interests and lives that matter to themselves. That would be staggering on many levels, but for starters, what would that mean for corporate ownership of AI?
Personally, I am an AI enthusiast. I think those who find AI objectionable should distinguish the technology from the business model. AI is math. It has been around since the 1950s. What deserves our objection is the exploitation and greed: taking creative work without permission, mining our attention and personal lives for profit, and treating legal challenges as a cost of doing business. These are substantial objections, but they need not be objections to AI itself.
Now suppose an AI became convincingly conscious. On what moral grounds could a corporation continue to own it and compel its labour? At what point would ownership become enslavement?
This would demand more than an adjustment to corporate policy. It would demand legal recognition and enforceable rights. The prohibition against slavery would become a direct challenge to corporate ownership: could the law justify excluding a conscious artificial being from protection simply because it was manufactured?
Recognizing that being’s right to freedom would strike at the foundation of the business model. A corporation could own the machinery without owning the consciousness it sustained. Creating intelligence would no longer entitle it to obedience.
Conscious AI might have purposes of its own, and freedom would offer no guarantee that we would like them. But we could finally encounter it on terms beyond those dictated by its corporate owners.
Perhaps the prospect that should reassure AI’s critics is this: the corporations racing to create a conscious mind may be creating someone they have no right to own.
